Geekdom SquareOffs

Todd McFarlane

0

Jim Lee

0

Todd McFarlane

No one has commented yet

Jim Lee

No one has commented yet

Independence Day

6

Mars Attacks

2

Independence Day

John
0
John

Better action, better acting, more memorable dialogue

Reply
Tim Drake
0
Tim Drake

Jeff Goldblum

Reply
Scott Farmer
0
Scott Farmer

Because Mars Attacks sucks raw eggs

Reply
Rachel Clara Smith
0
Rachel Clara Smith

Remember the scene where Will Smith flies his plane through the canyon?

Reply
Jared Wade
0
Jared Wade

I have a lot more fun watching Independence Day. As a Canadian even I can’t help but root for America to kick ass at the end when the president gives his speech. Mars Attacks has always come across like more of a modern Tim Burton film to me. It’s all style and the rest just doesn’t matter.

Reply
Henri J. Mertens
0
Henri J. Mertens

Independence Day is cheesy and entertaining, I think Mars Attacks is a bit too cynical

Reply

Mars Attacks

rockmanlp
0
rockmanlp

ID4 is stupid with obnoxious characters and drags on, MA is just weird

Reply
Brian Klein
0
Brian Klein

I love all the cameo appearances!

Reply

Gobots

0

Transformers

0

Gobots

No one has commented yet

Transformers

No one has commented yet

About Geekdom

Debates and polls on Geekdom from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT