Husker Max

Husker Max

huskermax.com
Everything you ever wanted to know about the Huskers www.huskermax.com
Is Nick Saban the best college football coach of all time?
Husker Max Asked by Husker Max
2/12/2016

Is Nick Saban the best college football coach of all time?

25%
Yes

2

75%
No WINNER

25

25%
Yes

2 Comments
Sean Fluharty
0
Sean Fluharty

What he has been able to accomplish, in today's world of parity in college football, is nothing short of amazing.

Reply

75%
No

24 Comments
Randy Wolf
18
Randy Wolf

SEC gets the athletes these days. Easy to coach when you have those kids. Best coach in SEC? Yes.

Reply
Larry Baumann
Larry Baumann

And it sure as HELL will never be that stupid ass RILEY!

Scott Roth
3
Scott Roth

Can't compare eras. Osborne retired when he was five years younger than Saban is now--who knows if he would have won more? Wilkinson, Bryant, Rockne, Leahy? Only a partial list. Yes, he is great. but let's just calm down with the superlatives. No one has to be the best ever...

Reply
Mark Larson
3
Mark Larson

2ND .......to Tom Osborne, of course !

Reply
Kevin Hamilton
2
Kevin Hamilton

If he had done what he has done at Alabama at Michigan State I would say yes! However doing so at a school like Alabama with the resources and SEC I say hell no. In my opinion TO would have 10 titles if he coached at bama not three.

Reply
Jim Kohout
2
Jim Kohout

He's not even the best all time coach at Alabama!

Reply
Randy Pappas
1
Randy Pappas

He bailed at Michigan State.Smart on his part to be in recruit heaven when he went to the South.Great Coach,best of all time no

Reply
Arlie Rauch
1
Arlie Rauch

No way to prove he is--too many factors involved. Number of championships statistically puts him up high, but… How about outcomes in the lives of young men?

Reply
John Willets Jr.
1
John Willets Jr.

All I can say is Bud Wilkinson from Oklahoma.

Reply
Jeremy Hall
1
Jeremy Hall

By far, the best recruiter. Not close to the best coach.

Reply
Jerry Williams
1
Jerry Williams

Access to crop of great athletes within recruiting area. A very good coach and has hired a good staff. But can not compare different time periods.

Reply
Tim Lowe
1
Tim Lowe

You're kidding, right???

Reply
Dwayne Cuypers
1
Dwayne Cuypers

Gut feeling. The man has zero integrity. SPARTY.LSU.D Dolphins. Tide

Reply
Mike Underwood
1
Mike Underwood

Bear, Switzer, Osborne, and Bowden didn't have social media at their disposal. Access to recruits is literally at the end of Saban's fingertips. Old school coaches had to actually hit the road and FIND players.

Reply
Visitor
1
Visitor

when he can win by not cheating at Recruiting by over singing recruits and still have success without 5 star players then maybe he will be compared to Osborn

Reply
Gene Brantz
0
Gene Brantz

The Bear at Bama is still #1, followed by Bud Wilkinson and Tom Osborne.

Reply
Nichol Pickerill
0
Nichol Pickerill

Too many losses compared to other coaches at this point in his career. Didn't earn 2 title games but SEC bias put Bama in despite better, more worthy teams from elsewhere.

Reply
Roy Watson
0
Roy Watson

Best recruiter, yes. Best coach? I can't say since I would be comparing him to all other coaches that were under different coaches throughout the years, including Bear Bryant.

Reply
Thomas J Morehead
0
Thomas J Morehead

When you continually get the best players it is not hard to win. Try recruiting to the middle of nowhere and win 3 championship in 4 years with 3 star players.

Reply
Joseph Sanchez
0
Joseph Sanchez

It just came up, he's a great head coach, he gets the best recruits in the country, which alot of teams in ncca football don't if coach for another twam not in the power conferance, he would not win .fair

Reply
James Traut
0
James Traut

"All time" is too broad in comparing different eras. In the mid 20th century, 20-30 years constituted an era. By the end of the 20th, it was down to 20 years. Now in the 21st, it's shortened to 10 years as so many changes in budgets, recruiting, player development, and stay in college vs. the NFL...

Reply
Keith Petrie
0
Keith Petrie

Are you kidding??? He crashed and burned at Miami!

Reply
Is it reasonable to consider Nebraska a potential playoff team in 2025?

Is it reasonable to consider Nebraska a potential playoff team in 2025?

Yes, it just might happen

6

No, that's crazy talk

16

Yes, it just might happen

6 Comments
Jeff Shaw
0
Jeff Shaw

Qb. Oline. Offense could be very good. Back 7 on d should be good Concerns at rb depth and unknowns on interiour d line.

Reply
Terrence Smith
0
Terrence Smith

With their schedule, they might be able to make it this year.

Reply
Chester Ogborn
0
Chester Ogborn

They are as much a potential playoff team as Arizona State and Indiana were last year. There is no harm is fans dreaming big. A team with a recent history like Nebraska is going to put it together this year. Why not the Huskers?

Reply
Joe Nigro
0
Joe Nigro

Just wishful thinking but I believe the talent is there. We will need a few breaks but it is possible.

Reply
George mcdaniel
0
George mcdaniel

It had to do with mindset confidence and luck

Reply
Matt
0
Matt

They have a schedule that gets to the year 3 Matt Rhule 10 wins. If they can hang with Penn St. then they could be in the conversation as a 10-2, 11-1 team.

Reply

No, that's crazy talk

16 Comments
Bill Petty
0
Bill Petty

Anything can happen, but up until now, Rhule hasn't shown that he can get the job done. I hope I'm wrong, but I just can't by the hype. Show me on the field.

Reply
Chad Alexander
0
Chad Alexander

So tired of delusional preseason talk. How about a winning conference record and a bowl win.

Reply
Eric Picquet
0
Eric Picquet

They haven’t done anything on the field to warrant that expectation. But there is nothing wrong with the team setting it as a goal and striving to reach that goal.

Reply
Charlie Knapper
0
Charlie Knapper

Haven't proven anything, yet.

Reply
Mike O
0
Mike O

Immanuel Kant would say no, but he had a very strict definition of reason. I can only imagine him pooh-poohing the Huskers because Rhule is compulsed to pass the ball on clear running downs. Afraid to actually hand the ball to the fullback on 3rd and 1. And instead is in the shotgun. NO THEY KANT!

Reply
Bob Flanagan
0
Bob Flanagan

Thry’ll be better this year, but I think 9-3 or 8-4 are likely which keeps them out of contention this year. My hope is that by year 4 under Rhule will finally get them ibto the playoff picture

Reply
Brad Mcbride
0
Brad Mcbride

They are a 6-6 football team until proven otherwise.

Reply
Chin Sin Chong
0
Chin Sin Chong

No on field results to support that yet. History told us talks are simply empty statements

Reply
Roy Katskee
0
Roy Katskee

NU has not demonstrated that they belong.

Reply
Melvyn Halfon
0
Melvyn Halfon

NU has not been able to recruit top notch players. The media has led fans to believe that 3 star players can be molded into 4 and 5 stars. That dog don’t hunt?

Reply
Richard Johnson
0
Richard Johnson

They need to prove they belong. Still to ,many players on the squad that played on bad teams and don't know how to win yet.

Reply
Greg Engel
0
Greg Engel

I just can’t let myself get my hopes up too high. I am hopeful for a good season, though

Reply
Kevin Hubbell
0
Kevin Hubbell

Let's not put the cart before the horse! 7 or 8 wins maybe.

Reply
Dan Larsen
0
Dan Larsen

Let's consider a few "bigger" bowl game victories first.... way to early!

Reply
Joe Hegarty
0
Joe Hegarty

That's crazy alright. Just hope they make a bowl game again.

Reply
Is Marques Watson‑Trent the Big Ten’s top linebacker?
Husker Max Asked by Husker Max
6 months left

Is Marques Watson‑Trent the Big Ten’s top linebacker?

Absolutely

1

Not quite

1

Absolutely

1 Comment
John Haller
0
John Haller

He was a tackling machine with a less talented defensive line in front of him at Georgia Southern. He will have bigger gaps and less linemen reaching him IMO

Reply

Not quite

1 Comment
Mike O
0
Mike O

Dick Butkus is the best Big Ten linebacker. But Watson-Trent might be the best ever with a hyphen in his name. Jack Ham is the best Big Ten linebacker to have the middle name Raphael. LaVar Arrington is the best to have a capital V inexpliccably inserted into his frist name. The list goes on.

Reply

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT