Nebraskafootball SquareOffs

Will Nebraska's intentional offseason mindset show up in a tougher run defense this fall?
267 2
Will Nebraska's intentional offseason mindset show up in a tougher run defense this fall?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Elijah Pritchett take the leap at left tackle Nebraska needs in 2026?
239 3
Will Elijah Pritchett take the leap at left tackle Nebraska needs in 2026?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Nebraska's special teams remain one of its most reliable units without Mike Ekeler?
404 5
Will Nebraska's special teams remain one of its most reliable units without Mike Ekeler?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Nebraska's running backs rush for 1,000+ yards combined in 2026?
651 14
Will Nebraska's running backs rush for 1,000+ yards combined in 2026?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will 4-star safety Tory Pittman III keep his Nebraska commitment after visiting LSU?
195 0
Will 4-star safety Tory Pittman III keep his Nebraska commitment after visiting LSU?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Nebraska's 2027 football recruiting class finish in the top 15 nationally?
480 6
Will Nebraska's 2027 football recruiting class finish in the top 15 nationally?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Anthony Colandrea lead Nebraska football to more than eight wins in 2026?
405 4
Will Anthony Colandrea lead Nebraska football to more than eight wins in 2026?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Is Nebraska in any real danger of losing the commitments of Trae Taylor and/or Tory Pittman?
417 8
Is Nebraska in any real danger of losing the commitments of Trae Taylor and/or Tory Pittman?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Thoughts on the $600 million Memorial Stadium renovation plan?
364 10
Thoughts on the $600 million Memorial Stadium renovation plan?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Jamal Rule start at RB for Nebraska's 2026 opener?
409 3
Will Jamal Rule start at RB for Nebraska's 2026 opener?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Will Riley Van Poppel take a noticeable jump under Nebraska’s new DL coaching?
244 3
Will Riley Van Poppel take a noticeable jump under Nebraska’s new DL coaching?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Who do you think will be the leading rusher for the Huskers over the next two years?
273 0
Who do you think will be the leading rusher for the Huskers over the next two years?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Do you think Adrian Martinez will come back for a 5th year?
425 4
Do you think Adrian Martinez will come back for a 5th year?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
After two good, tough, but heartbreaking games how are you feeling about the Northwestern game?
151 1
After two good, tough, but heartbreaking games how are you feeling about the Northwestern game?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max
Do you see the Huskers beating the point spread against Oklahoma this weekend?
535 16
Do you see the Huskers beating the point spread against Oklahoma this weekend?
Husker Max
Asked By
Husker Max

Not #1 but yes

3

No he wouldn't have

10

Not #1 but yes

trainssker
0
trainssker

I think he’d have adapted. He might not have been early first round but I think he’d have been in the first round. IMO... he had better receivers here than at LSU! 😁

Reply
trevors951
0
trevors951

not like LSU was lighting the wrld on fire b4 He got there. the no talent point at NU is overplayed to cover 4 lack of play-calling, dvlpment etc esp with top 25 classes and outrecruiting BTWest oppo

Reply
RJ Heinen
0
RJ Heinen

He would have been sacked a lot and if he could withstand the injury bug then yes late first round.

Reply

No he wouldn't have

Tom Nelsen
2
Tom Nelsen

It takes more than one player to be successful. Without a solid line and multiple talented targets, Joe wouldn't have risen above obscurity in my opinion. If he played for a 90's Husker team-yes

Reply
Randy Wolf
0
Randy Wolf

Frost is too in love with Martinez. Which means the best quarterback on the roster this season will not play.

Reply
Randy Weitzenkamp
0
Randy Weitzenkamp

Frost was stuck on Martinez, 3rd stringers rarely get drafted in the 1st round.

Reply
Shane Schmidt
0
Shane Schmidt

Lsu is a top notch program in the SEC Nebraska hasn't been a top notch program in over 20 years!

Reply
Doug Miller
0
Doug Miller

And wouldn't have won the Heisman.

Reply
Ron Joseph
0
Ron Joseph

As others have said, it takes a whole team. He would have been average at best here because we don't have the OL or skilled players to allow him to rise to the top. Hopefully we will soon for a QB

Reply
Paul F Edwards
0
Paul F Edwards

If he would have done better than Martinez, it would not have been by much. With essentially horrible line play, no running or passing game, no QB could have done much better

Reply
Lonty Bryant
0
Lonty Bryant

Not enough talent up front

Reply
Matt Seiler
0
Matt Seiler

The O line is definitely trending upward but between bad pass pro at times and not enough play making receivers, no QB could have had a great year with the Huskers last year.

Reply
John Pankonin
0
John Pankonin

Would not have had the line protection nor the receiver speed.

Reply

Rich Glover

3

Ndamukong Suh

10

Rich Glover

David McClymont
1
David McClymont

Tough choice. Suh was physically stronger but when you compare effectiveness of the player vs state of the game when they played it's harder to say. Also, RG had 2 outstanding seasons vs NS's 1.

Reply
Johnny Joyce
0
Johnny Joyce

Rich was a one many wrecking ball on a National Championship team competing with his own players like Larry Jacobson, etc.

Reply
Tony Bunting
0
Tony Bunting

It's very close. Each was the dominant defensive lineman of his era. Each wrecked offenses. Glover by far outplayed everyone in the Game of the Century, and it's hard to top that. Glover, barely.

Reply

Ndamukong Suh

Fred Gibson
0
Fred Gibson

I was only about 10 when Rich Glover played. I remember him as an awesome player but Suh is arguably the greatest college D-Lineman of all time. Not just at Nebraska, but all college, All time.

Reply
Steve “S85” T
0
Steve “S85” T

Suuuuuhhhhhhhhh!!!

Reply
Matt Miller
0
Matt Miller

How is this even a question?

Reply
Ron Joseph
0
Ron Joseph

SUH had less help on the Dline and yet he dominated. Ask that Missouri QB what he thinks as well as McCoy. If we had had the 2008 or 2010 offense wt Suh's 2009 D = National champs. Timing was off.

Reply
Nate Terwilleger
0
Nate Terwilleger

A beast often double & triple teamed, Suh still dominated games and caused OCs to change entire game plans mid-stream.

Reply
John Fillmore
0
John Fillmore

Glover was very good, but Suh's success in the NFL is a pretty good indicator of his overall talent level.

Reply
Rob Wiseman
0
Rob Wiseman

Suh has to double teamed in the nfl....Dominate is too small of a word.

Reply
Mel Nuss
0
Mel Nuss

Im old enough to have seen both play but Rich Glover had a great supporting cast. Suh didnt and he was a one man wrecking crew.

Reply
Jon Jorgenson
0
Jon Jorgenson

Glover was the best until Suh. More diverse offenses today. Nationally, Suh had a tad more recognition. I love them both and grateful they played for the Big Ref.

Reply

Turner Gill

7

Tommie Frazier

16

Turner Gill

Rick Shaneyfelt
0
Rick Shaneyfelt

Turner could do it all. He was equally an excellent runner and passer. And he was a great leader. He would have won 2 NCs if not for 2 terrible calls in the 82 Penn State game and a mediocre D in 83.

Reply
Sean Kelly
0
Sean Kelly

28-2 with 5 points being the difference between being undefeated.

Reply
Ian Paisley
0
Ian Paisley

Class and revolutionized the position.

Reply
gstegman@cox.net
0
gstegman@cox.net

The best all around. He could throw better than Frazier. His problem was that his defense wasn’t that good and two of the teams top players got bought off.

Reply
Rob Wiseman
0
Rob Wiseman

Gill was magic...The camera crew never knew where the ball was...best option qb of all time Gill.

Reply
Lonty Bryant
0
Lonty Bryant

There is no I in team

Reply
Brent Tammy Boettcher
Brent Tammy Boettcher

There's not one in MVP, either, but Tommie has three of those, as well.

Frank Johnson
0
Frank Johnson

Both were great. I enjoyed watch Turner more than I did Tommy.

Reply

Tommie Frazier

David French
1
David French

I have great respect for Turner and what he has done for the Nebraska football program both as a player and as a former coach. With that being said Tommie led NU to 2 National championships. Turner 0

Reply
Mike Petersen
0
Mike Petersen

Two NC's, but odd that you didn't include the one who won the Heisman in this discussion.

Reply
Randy Weitzenkamp
0
Randy Weitzenkamp

I'd take Turner Gill everyday of the week and twice on Saturday. I also get that Tommie had much better defensive support than what Turner had. However, in the end Tommie has 2 Natty's.

Reply
gray llama
0
gray llama

Scott frost is best.

Reply
Kim Brown
0
Kim Brown

He's a winner!

Reply
David McClymont
0
David McClymont

MVP in three bowl games that determined the National Championship. TF was at his absolute best in the biggest games. To come back and play great against Miami after missing 3 months was amazing.

Reply
Tony Bunting
0
Tony Bunting

I love them both. They are the two best QBs in Nebraska history. Frazier gets the nod because of the NCs, though Gill could have won two, also.

Reply
Doug Clark
0
Doug Clark

I think Turner is so close to Tommie in numbers, but 2 Naty’s is a heck of a tie breaker. Tommy won when Turner didn’t.

Reply
Rick Chambers
0
Rick Chambers

Tommie was the best option Q-back I have ever seen at Nebraska, point blank

Reply
Brent Tammy Boettcher
0
Brent Tammy Boettcher

We all know it takes great TEAMS to win the titles, and Frazier arguably had better overall teams. But it isn't just that. He was the MVP of three straight title games. No one else has that.

Reply
Joel Schneekloth
0
Joel Schneekloth

This was a tough call. I take Tommy by a hair. Loved Turner Gill as well.

Reply
Roy Bishop
0
Roy Bishop

2 titles and he made everyone accountable

Reply
Sean Fluharty
0
Sean Fluharty

There was no better big-game QB than Frazier... MVP of 3 straight NCG.

Reply
Ron Joseph
Ron Joseph

I agree. Some years ago, some publication stated that Tommie was the all time best college QB because of leadership & not because of individual stats. Turner was great and really should have had 2 NC

About Nebraskafootball

Debates and polls on Nebraskafootball from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT