Draft - SquareOffs

Asked by Walter Football

11/3/2014

Which draft day trade was a bigger bust for the Jaguars?

37%

Derrick Harvey

63%

Blaine Gabbert WINNER

37%

Derrick Harvey

Which draft day trade was a bigger bust for the Jaguars?

The Jags traded four picks including their 1st rounder to the Ravens for the right to select Harvey #8 in the 2008 NFL Draft. Harvey only made it 3 seasons in Jacksonville befor... Show More

The Jags traded four picks including their 1st rounder to the Ravens for the right to select Harvey #8 in the 2008 NFL Draft. Harvey only made it 3 seasons in Jacksonville before flaming out of the league following a stop in Denver and Cincy the following two seasons. Show Less

3 Comments

Brytyr

Gabbert was bad but people forget Garrard basically had a career ending injury which left them with Luke McCown as their only QB, also Gene Smith was a horrid GM anyway. The Harvey pick is the bigger busy because of the amount of picks traded and how that equated to a Super Bowl win for the Ratbirds. The Gabbert bust just allowed the Washington Football Team to acquire BustG3.

Jay Barron

Being a Ravens fan, I know that this trade got the ball rolling for them to obtain both Flacco and Rice in this draft. The Jaguars could have gotten both those players instead!

Matt Wemer

Derrick Morgan had great expectations to be a great DE and a cornerstone of the defense. Blaine Gabbert, although bad, always had a cloud around him from day one. He was drafted way too high, in a position impossible to succeed without significant help. Gabbert was an awful pick and set the Jags back at least 2-3 years, but Morgan was supposed to be a slam dunk

63%

Blaine Gabbert

In 2011 the Redskins happily traded their #10 selection to the Jags in exchange for there 1st and 2nd round picks. Gabbert never progressed as the QB of the future and is curren... Show More

In 2011 the Redskins happily traded their #10 selection to the Jags in exchange for there 1st and 2nd round picks. Gabbert never progressed as the QB of the future and is currently holding a clipboard for the 49ers. Think the Jags wish they would have taken J.J. Watt who was picked one spot later at #11? Show Less

2 Comments

Alec Tolivaisa

They released David Garrard, the most underrated QB of the 2000's for this bum!!! The franchise tanked when this happened.

Tyler Fapptastic Houston

David garrad wasn't great....but he was way better than gabbet ever was...harvey at least got 8 sacks....gabbert just existed.

Asked by Walter Football

11/20/2014

How many QB's will go in the 2015 NFL Draft first round?

0%

2 or fewer WINNER

0%

3 or more

0%

2 or fewer

0 Comment

No one has commented yet

0%

3 or more

0 Comment

No one has commented yet

Asked by Walter Football

11/27/2014

Who will have better NFL success?

70%

Marcus Mariota WINNER

30%

Jameis WInston

70%

Marcus Mariota

7 Comments

Andy Ruggiero-Smith

He is the superior player and the superior person. The steelers should look at Winston ... that way they can groom the next rapist behind their current rapist.

Lance Richie

Winston is a headcase. No way he will have a better career.

Eddie Tacito MacNish

Accurate, elusive, and is patient in the pocket. He's not afraid to move between his progressions, and in the end, he sure can run.

Visitor

Footwork, footwork, footwork. You cannot be accurate without footwork. You cannot be successful without footwork. Sorry Blake Bortles, but footwork is better than being 6'5" and 235 pounds with a cannon with no aim. Mariota will be a Pro Bowl caliber player in his very first season. That's why I voted for him, he's a fluffier version of Andrew Luck.

Benjamin Varner

Character

Mohamed

Mariota has better mechanics and probably has a better work ethic as opposed to the guy that looks like he's whipping a 100 MPH fastball and runs like he's had too many crab legs. Seriously, who yells "F her right in the .."

Justin Wall

Despite all of Winston's talent, I cannot see him staying out of trouble and becoming a successful leader in today's NFL.

30%

Jameis WInston

3 Comments

Johnson Uche

How many qbs that depend on their legs last in the NFL.... none Kapernick, Newton and Wilson are being exposed this year without an elite defense Winston is an ANdrew Luck type of talent, that can carry a team... hes doing it right now in college... Mariota loses to mediocre teams like arizona in his own house.... also mariota is injury prone

Visitor

Bruh, Arizona is going to win the Pac 12. Thats not mediocre.

Keith Beaumont

I just don't think that Mariota's game will translate to the NFL. For him to be successful, he will have to be drafted by a team that's a perfect fit. Oregon's playbook is the smallest in college football, Mariota's learning curve will therefore be extensive. Winston will probably suck too though, so I'm betting they both bust.

jubben

It's tough as obviously both are talented players. I think Mariota is more careful with the ball, but he reminds me too much of Manziel on how quickly he abandons the throw for the scramble. Winston has great arm strength and uses his mobility mostly to keep plays alive and always keeps his eyes down field. Also like Manziel, I think he could be one of the greats in the NFL if he can keep his nose clean.

Draft SquareOffs

Which draft day trade was a bigger bust for the Jaguars?

37% Derrick Harvey

63% Blaine Gabbert WINNER

37% Derrick Harvey

63% Blaine Gabbert

How many QB's will go in the 2015 NFL Draft first round?

0% 2 or fewer WINNER

0% 3 or more

0% 2 or fewer

0% 3 or more

Who will have better NFL success?

70% Marcus Mariota WINNER

30% Jameis WInston

70% Marcus Mariota

30% Jameis WInston

About Draft

37%

Derrick Harvey

63%

Blaine Gabbert WINNER

37%

Derrick Harvey

63%

Blaine Gabbert

0%

2 or fewer WINNER

0%

3 or more

0%

2 or fewer

0%

3 or more

70%

Marcus Mariota WINNER

30%

Jameis WInston

70%

Marcus Mariota

30%

Jameis WInston