Peterose SquareOffs

Should Pete Rose be in the Baseball Hall of Fame?
ABC 17 News Asked by ABC 17 News
233 Votes

Should Pete Rose be in the Baseball Hall of Fame?

Yes

0

No

0

Yes

0 Comment
No one has commented yet

No

0 Comment
No one has commented yet
Should Pete Rose be taken off the MLB's ineligible list?
Devlin Patrick Asked by Devlin Patrick
7/31/2020

Should Pete Rose be taken off the MLB's ineligible list?

67%
Yes! He is a legend! WINNER

0

33%
No! keep him out!

0

67%
Yes! He is a legend!

He is the all time hits leader in the MLB, he deserves to be in the HOF. Astros players are going unpunished after their recent cheating scandal; Pete should be let off the hook... Show More
He is the all time hits leader in the MLB, he deserves to be in the HOF. Astros players are going unpunished after their recent cheating scandal; Pete should be let off the hook for Gambling on his team 30 years ago. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet

33%
No! keep him out!

He was gambling on baseball while he was the manager of the Reds, he should stay banned. and the players found guilty of cheating on the Astros should become ineligible as well.
He was gambling on baseball while he was the manager of the Reds, he should stay banned. and the players found guilty of cheating on the Astros should become ineligible as well. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet
BBST Asked by BBST
2/14/2016

Has it been long enough that MLB should forgive Pete Rose?

58%
Yes! WINNER

2

42%
No Way!

3

58%
Yes!

2 Comments
BBST
19
BBST

Read the whole post and you'll find out!

Reply
James Tarver
3
James Tarver

He did nothing to change the outcome of a game. Fired or banned from.coaching is a fair punishment. He should be in the hall

Reply

42%
No Way!

2 Comments
Steve Sims
1
Steve Sims

Was betting on baseball games banned when Rose played? Even if he actually didn't bet against the Reds, he could have played worse in a few key games to pay off his debts. If it were banned, he shouldn't get the benefit of the doubt.

Reply
A.J. McCarty
1
A.J. McCarty

There was ONE rule at the time. He broke it. End of story.

Reply
Daniel Walton
Daniel Walton

I don't think he should be just totally shunned, but he shouldn't be put in the hall of fame, either. A lot of people are delusioned that the hall is ALL NUMBERS. It's NOT and it never should be.

Trending
ESports
NBA - Hot Topics 🔥
NFL 🏈
Home Run Baseball Debates ⚾️
Packers 
Who to Follow
Nathan Snyder
Nathan Snyder @nathan-snyder
Waira
Waira @ItsWaira
Husker Max
Husker Max @HuskerMax

About Peterose

Debates and polls on Peterose from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

Become a Partner

Get SquareOffs on Your Site

📱 Download the App: iOS

Support  Publishers  About  Blog  Shop   Facebook  Twitter  Instagram  Privacy  Terms  Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information  Community Guidelines © 2025 SquareOffs Social Polling Platform

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT