Sci-fi - SquareOffs

Who's portrayal of Luke Skywalker is better?

Asked by Patrick Stewart

276 Votes

Who's portrayal of Luke Skywalker is better?

38%

Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

62%

Favreau & Filoni nailed it Favreau & Filoni nailed it

38%

Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

Rian Craig John made a bold decision to take the legendary Luke Skywalker to a place he had never been as a character and gave him the ending he so richly deserved. By subvertin... Show More

Rian Craig John made a bold decision to take the legendary Luke Skywalker to a place he had never been as a character and gave him the ending he so richly deserved. By subverting fan expectations he gave us something that had never been done and breathed new life into Star Wars. Show Less

0 Comment

No one has commented yet

62%

Favreau & Filoni nailed it

Favreau & Filoni understand George Lucas' inent and vision for the character of Luke Skywalker. The portrayed Luke as the Jedi Master he truly is and honored fan expectations wi... Show More

Favreau & Filoni understand George Lucas' inent and vision for the character of Luke Skywalker. The portrayed Luke as the Jedi Master he truly is and honored fan expectations with the Luke we all know and love. Show Less

2 Comments

Brian Klein

I rewatched this scene many times over. Sorry to say, that is not the case with any of the sequel trilogy movies.

Patrick Stewart

Exactly. People can say what they want. But I have a whole series of reactions where I show my best friend Star Wars for the 1st time. Mando finale with awesome like has over 12k views. Sequel trilogy is only in the hundreds. Filoni and Favreau get it.

Patrick Stewart

Sometimes a new bold vision is what is needed; but in this case I believe RCJ's portrayal of Luke was disrespectful to Lucas, the character, and the fans. The Luke we saw in Mando was the Luke we have been wanting to see for 40 years.

Between these beloved episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation, which is the greatest?

Asked by Geekvolution

150 Votes

Between these beloved episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation, which is the greatest?

68%

"The Best of Both Worlds" "The Best of Both Worlds"

32%

"The Inner Light" "The Inner Light"

68%

"The Best of Both Worlds"

0 Comment

No one has commented yet

32%

"The Inner Light"

1 Comment

rockmanlp

The ending totally gets me. All our experiences and relationships, and the emotion that comes along with that. It's all real.

Should Fox make a Firefly revival series without Joss Whedon?

Asked by Geekvolution

340 Votes

Should Fox make a Firefly revival series without Joss Whedon?

36%

Yes, if most of the cast would come back Yes, if most of the cast would come back

64%

No, they should leave it alone No, they should leave it alone

36%

Yes, if most of the cast would come back

3 Comments

Damien Wade

Because the world is fascinating and there's some real possibilities for expansion there. They could easily use his "bible" but take it in their own direction.

Faith Samuels

I love him no one better

Ben Thompson

Just because the original creator is gone doesn't mean something good can't come out of it. If it's good enough for the entire cast to come back even without wheadon I'd say give it a chance

64%

No, they should leave it alone

5 Comments

Friendly Yoyo

It seems irrelevant. The cast is too old for their characters, the story is being told in books, comics, and other supplemental material.

Jedi Knight

I'm not exactly throwing parades for any decades later reboots.

rockmanlp

I never liked Firefly.

SpedeVesku

Even if there was no controversy around Whedon, the ship has sailed.

Brian Klein

I feel like it would be missing the magic without J.W.

Rachel Clara Smith

I completely agree.

Brian Klein

And if they couldn't get the O.G. cast back it would not be great.

Sci-fi SquareOffs

Who's portrayal of Luke Skywalker is better?

38% Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

62% Favreau & Filoni nailed it Favreau & Filoni nailed it

38% Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

62% Favreau & Filoni nailed it

Between these beloved episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation, which is the greatest?

68% "The Best of Both Worlds" "The Best of Both Worlds"

32% "The Inner Light" "The Inner Light"

68% "The Best of Both Worlds"

32% "The Inner Light"

Should Fox make a Firefly revival series without Joss Whedon?

36% Yes, if most of the cast would come back Yes, if most of the cast would come back

64% No, they should leave it alone No, they should leave it alone

36% Yes, if most of the cast would come back

64% No, they should leave it alone

About Sci-fi

38%

Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

62%

Favreau & Filoni nailed it Favreau & Filoni nailed it

38%

Rian Craig Johnson is a visionary

62%

Favreau & Filoni nailed it

68%

"The Best of Both Worlds" "The Best of Both Worlds"

32%

"The Inner Light" "The Inner Light"

68%

"The Best of Both Worlds"

32%

"The Inner Light"

36%

Yes, if most of the cast would come back Yes, if most of the cast would come back

64%

No, they should leave it alone No, they should leave it alone

36%

Yes, if most of the cast would come back

64%

No, they should leave it alone