Execution - SquareOffs

Should David Hosier have been executed for the Gilpin murders?

Asked by ABC 17 News

281 Votes

Should David Hosier have been executed for the Gilpin murders?

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

1 Comments

Max DeYoung

It took 15 years, way too long.

20%

No

3 Comments

Toasty

Not because he doesn't deserve the death penalty and the world would be a better place without him, the punishment is no longer a deterrent to violent crime. Too many appeals, to many mistakes, shady prosecutors, inept defense lawyers, etc..etc.

Belinda Kitchen

Yes&no 1) he took a life so yes he should be held accountable. 2) he had heart issues he should remain life in prison cause he would end life eventually. People who have medical conditions that's on death row should be life in prison instead of leathal injection.

Cheryl Smith

The death penalty makes you what you hate - a murderer. The death penalty makes you a hypocrite. The death penalty is nothing more than collectivized sadism. Abolish the death penalty!

Max DeYoung

Some Old Testament passages, such as Genesis 9:6, Exodus 21:12-16, Leviticus 24:17-20, Numbers 35:16-18, and Deuteronomy 22:25-27, permit or require capital punishment for serious crimes against human dignity, such as murder.

Was justice served in Ernest Johnson's execution?

Asked by ABC 17 News

574 Votes

Was justice served in Ernest Johnson's execution?

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

Johnson killed three people in 1994 at a Casey's General Store in Columbia.

Johnson killed three people in 1994 at a Casey's General Store in Columbia. Show Less

5 Comments

Max

Yes, but 25 years late.

Jesper Kraul Jensen

If anyone, he deserved a deathpenalty. Why victimize the perpetrator ?

AlanandLeila Hoyt

Evil action have consequences. Per his statement, he is aware of the wrong he committed. I believe in the value of all human life-but justice is necessary in order to keep society functioning and safe. It is unfortunate he made a choice that resulted in the death of 4, including himself.

Steve TheBmann

I knew Fred Jones and he was as nice of a guy as you could meet. He was not a threat to anyone, and he had his own mental challenges. The murderer did not care. I'm sure Fred will forgive him and God will do the final judgement. No happiness in the execution, at least closure. Justice served.

Sherry Scott Schafer

Can't bring list lives back but he intentionally one by one savagely murdered three innocent people.

20%

No

Advocates for Johnson argued his intellectual disability would make executing him unconstitutional.

Advocates for Johnson argued his intellectual disability would make executing him unconstitutional. Show Less

1 Comment

Kat Hanson

I believe jail I better not taking someone's life that doesn't solve anything

Max

Capital Punishment for Capital Crime. Jail is for non violent crime.

Should the state execute Ernest Lee Johnson?

Asked by ABC 17 News

564 Votes

Should the state execute Ernest Lee Johnson?

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

A jury convicted Johnson in 1994 of the murders of three people at a Columbia convenience store. The murder weapon was a claw hammer.

A jury convicted Johnson in 1994 of the murders of three people at a Columbia convenience store. The murder weapon was a claw hammer. Show Less

5 Comments

Connie Sullivan

Enough is enough.

Donna Welborn-Dicus

This was not a passive murder (shooting), he actively beat these three victims to death with a HAMMER.

Max

This man beat the victims with a hammer, with such savagery that the initial investigation, it was thought that they had been shot in their faces with a large shotgun. He should have been put down many years ago.

Will Mason

It is time to stop wasting money on this fool. He should have been executed years ago.

N A

the death penalty is actually far more expensive than a system that utilizes life in prison

Chris Hill

Against the death penalty in general, but then there are cases like this one.

20%

No

Death penalty foes are trying to get the governor to spare Johnson after other legal efforts failed to get him off death row. They say Johnson is intellectually disabled.

Death penalty foes are trying to get the governor to spare Johnson after other legal efforts failed to get him off death row. They say Johnson is intellectually disabled. Show Less

3 Comments

N A

regardless of your stance on the death penalty, the supreme court clearly established in 2002 that it is considered "cruel and unusual punishment" to execute someone with a mental disability. Johnson repeatedly scored below the comprehension level of a 5 yr old on disability tests.

Christopher Watson

Two wrongs don't make a right, it's NOT justice, it's revenge, that is evil. Makes you no better than the Perp.

N A

in response to max de young: 1. no one was advocating this man ever be freed from prison 2. the death penalty is proven to not reduce the amount of violent crimes in a country

Max

But it will prevent another wrong, and that may save an undetermined amount of lives.

Letitia DenHartog

There is no way of knowing whether he understood what he was doing when he killed the people.

Max

I'm pretty certain the people he beat to death also failed to understand him too.

Who to Follow

Execution SquareOffs

Should David Hosier have been executed for the Gilpin murders?

80% Yes Yes

20% No No

80% Yes

20% No

Was justice served in Ernest Johnson's execution?

80% Yes Yes

20% No No

80% Yes

20% No

Should the state execute Ernest Lee Johnson?

80% Yes Yes

20% No No

80% Yes

20% No

About Execution

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

20%

No

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

20%

No

80%

Yes Yes

20%

No No

80%

Yes

20%

No