Spiderman SquareOffs

AMC Asked by AMC
12/9/2014

AMC VERSUS - Who was the better Spider-Man actor?

40%
Tobey Maguire

0

60%
Andrew Garfield WINNER

0

40%
Tobey Maguire

AMC VERSUS - Who was the better Spider-Man actor?
0 Comment
No one has commented yet

60%
Andrew Garfield

AMC VERSUS - Who was the better Spider-Man actor?
0 Comment
No one has commented yet
Jon Schnepp Asked by Jon Schnepp
8/11/2014

Who is the best Spider-Man?

43%
Andrew Garfield

0

57%
Tobey McGuire WINNER

1

43%
Andrew Garfield

Who is the best Spider-Man?
A true fan of Spider-Man, this lankier actor is a better representation of the actual comics.
A true fan of Spider-Man, this lankier actor is a better representation of the actual comics. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet

57%
Tobey McGuire

Who is the best Spider-Man?
He effectively embodied the key elements of relatability, nerdiness and emotional depth.
He effectively embodied the key elements of relatability, nerdiness and emotional depth. Show Less
1 Comment
Smol-Vampire
0
Smol-Vampire

no questions asked Maguire is better

Reply
Trending
Marvel Cinematic Universe
Anime
My Hero Academia
Cartoons!
Horror
Would You Rather? 🤷🏻‍♀️
Who to Follow
Patrick Stewart
Patrick Stewart @patrickstewart
Skye pie
Skye pie @skye-pie
The React Pack
The React Pack @TheReactPack

About Spiderman

Debates and polls on Spiderman from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

Become a Partner

Get SquareOffs on Your Site

📱 Download the App: iOS

Support  Publishers  About  Blog  Shop   Facebook  Twitter  Instagram  Privacy  Terms  Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information  Community Guidelines © 2026 SquareOffs Social Polling Platform

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT