Host of Superhero Rewind and The Captain Logan Show on YouTube! Reviewing superhero media, comics and other geeky stuff since 2009!
Would you rather watch The Phantom Menace or The Force Awakens?

Would you rather watch The Phantom Menace or The Force Awakens?

Phantom Menace

7

Force Awakens

6

Phantom Menace

7 Comments
Rikard Andersson
2
Rikard Andersson

Phantom Menace is at least some what original, Force Awakens is an inferior remake Why watch Force Awakens when I can watch A New Hope instead?

Reply
Robert Cherryman
2
Robert Cherryman

I’m fine watching either one but this film has better moments and more interesting failures

Reply
Frank Short
1
Frank Short

Epic lightsaber duels and nostalgia factor.

Reply
Andrew Cozzini
1
Andrew Cozzini

In my opinion, "The Force Awakens" was, as George approximates it, a "nostalgic" movie that, imo, for the first time since the prequels, regressed the franchise. "The Phantom Menace," (and KOTOR) pushed the needle forward, rethinking what Star Wars could be, adding many iconic elements to the lore.

Reply
VideoGameSecrets
0
VideoGameSecrets

The other two sequel movies ruined Force Awakens for me, and at least with Phantom Menace I fall asleep every time I watch it, so I get to see about the first half, which is nice.

Reply
Abe Unger
0
Abe Unger

The way George made his films feel like a 1930s Shakespearean serial is astounding, and Phantom Menace is both fun and thought provoking in its narrative. Now this is Star Wars!

Reply
Brennan Barrett
0
Brennan Barrett

The prequels are the Star Wars films I grew up with. While The Force Awakens is probably an objectively better film, how the Sequel Trilogy turned out as a whole ruins the films individually for me. Phantom Menace is just pure nostalgia for me. Plus pod racing and that final light saber duel!

Reply

Force Awakens

6 Comments
Conner Nielsen
2
Conner Nielsen

The prequels are amateurishly made.

Reply
Spencer Nielsen
0
Spencer Nielsen

Because The Force Awakens is a good movie?? Who would willingly, casually watch The Phantom Menace?

Reply
SpedeVesku
0
SpedeVesku

Of course I rather watch a good movie.

Reply
Mutale Mwananshiku
0
Mutale Mwananshiku

Even though its a rehash of ANH its still more entertaining to watch than the phantom menace.

Reply
Bluedragonfive
0
Bluedragonfive

Despite a weak finish in its respective trilogy it was a very promising start that has alotta enjoyable moments vs moments or characters I dread rewatching.

Reply
NICOLAS GARCIA
0
NICOLAS GARCIA

The characters in this for more fleshed out and are given their own identity, voice, and goal. Not all character share the same goal even Rey and Finn as they are together but clearly want different things for themselves. Finn's arc in this film alone is great especially. Acting is far better too.

Reply
Would Sonic the Hedgehog 3 perform fine without Jim Carrey if he decides not to do it?

Would Sonic the Hedgehog 3 perform fine without Jim Carrey if he decides not to do it?

Yes-- the franchise has legs without him

1

No-- he's necessary to its success

1

Yes-- the franchise has legs without him

1 Comment
DIMWITMONKEY
0
DIMWITMONKEY

Jim Carry's performance is only one of the many positives of both films. It may not be AS good or enjoyable, but the Sonic films have shown to be better than they have any right to be outside of Carry's performance. It would be a great time to introduce characters that have yet to make an appearance

Reply

No-- he's necessary to its success

1 Comment
Colin Carroll
0
Colin Carroll

he is a legend he makes the movie

Reply
Should the next on screen Wolverine be short and scrappy like he is in the comics?

Should the next on screen Wolverine be short and scrappy like he is in the comics?

Yes, that would set him apart

1

No, general audiences won't accept it

0

Yes, that would set him apart

1 Comment
Andrew Cozzini
1
Andrew Cozzini

While I certainly can appreciate a comic-accurate build for Logan this time 'round, personally, I'm more hopeful he suits up in a form of his traditional uniform, cowl and all! IMO, that would instantly separate this new version from Jackman's, regardless of his relative height to his predecessor.

Reply

No, general audiences won't accept it

0 Comment
No one has commented yet

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT