if instead of All Might they put Gran Torino then I'd say he takes it. Because of him Deku is now able to actually use his quirk properly.

Urodaki is definitely a better teacher cause lets be honest when it came down to all might needing to help deku get control of his quirk he didn't really provide any helpful information to help deku achieve that

He actually explains how stuff works. And all All Might did was tell him one thing over and over again

This was a hard decision because being a Good role Model and being a Good teacher are completly diffrent things, All Might is the best example for that he is a great role model but sucks as a teacher in the end i voted for the better teacher which is Urokodaki.

how did you guys (react pack) vote?

Tanjiro has actually progressed in a season. It took Midoriya 3 seasons to make any real progress.

As a teacher urokidaki is better as he's a teacher with proper training methods and also advices for tanjiro to progress and trained him for 6 months to improve his physical abilities, whereas in case of all might he is seen only on 3 occasions teaching, even full cowling was taught to deku by gran

While I do believe that All might is a better role model given his personality and persona, Urokodaki is a better teacher since he was able to give Tanjiro and the other kids very important lessons on how they should be fighting demons and using their senses to their fullest. he is strict but loving