Christmasmovie SquareOffs

45%
Tim Allen in “The Santa Clause"

9

55%
Edmund Gwenn in “Miracle on 34th Street” WINNER

14

45%
Tim Allen in “The Santa Clause"

9 Comments
marguerite malpica
0
marguerite malpica

Because he's just Santa Claus right from the start! He makes an incredible transformation in the beginning of the movie, and then throughout the movie his son keeps him believing that he's truly The Santa Claus!! Great Movie 🎥

Reply
Ken Weis
0
Ken Weis

Is because he is the best one to do it because he is funny, and he is serious when it comes down to do Santa Claus.

Reply
Sherri Sneed
0
Sherri Sneed

Tim’s Santa feels like a real person as opposed to a mythical one.

Reply
Sofia Duncan
0
Sofia Duncan

cause he good I like him playing Santa

Reply
Sofia Duncan
0
Sofia Duncan

cause he good I like him playing Santa

Reply
MonoTheBoyo (RoboDestroyer69)
0
MonoTheBoyo (RoboDestroyer69)

This is the one I actually watched when I was younger and I love the twist at the beginning of the movie

Reply
Rita Hewett
0
Rita Hewett

I've seen all Tim's The Santa Clause movies AND all the episodes of his new Santa Clauses. Looking forward to seeing his latest. He's truly a funny guy.

Reply
Fran L.
0
Fran L.

I am familiar with Tim Allen as I grew up watching Home Improvement & Last Man Standing. Maybe if I had watched Edmund's performance I would pick him but I have a feeling that it still would not change my vote and love for the one and only Tim Allen 👍🎄

Reply
Seamus Noah Matthewson (GingerCubbieBear)
0
Seamus Noah Matthewson (GingerCubbieBear)

Do to the comic version though tim Allen is very good at being a Santa though the other actor won a Oscar he help pavement the way to other great actors and the remake of miracle of 34th Street and now it's all good

Reply

55%
Edmund Gwenn in “Miracle on 34th Street”

14 Comments
Deborah Lester
1
Deborah Lester

It made you believe in Christmas!

Reply
Hijag Wilson
1
Hijag Wilson

This Christmas movie is the best ever made. I enjoyed watching year after year while growing up. Also, still enjoy it watching today as if it was my first time. It’s an excellent excellent movie. It’s what Christmas is all about. 🥰

Reply
pcairo@yahoo.com
0
pcairo@yahoo.com

He looks like Santa Clause

Reply
Chris W. McClendon
0
Chris W. McClendon

I guess I'm just a traditionalist. And Edmund Gwenn represents Christmas to me. A close second would be Kurt Russell!!!

Reply
Saprina Bowman
0
Saprina Bowman

He was the epitome of a real Santa Claus that made you question if he really could be real, even as an adult.

Reply
Gina Mendez
0
Gina Mendez

Because Classic! So meaningful, and the feeling of Christmas

Reply
Donna Thomas
0
Donna Thomas

More serious and old school.

Reply
Lori Hoppe
0
Lori Hoppe

The original Santa is always the best. And, who can resist a British accent? Huh?

Reply
Beverly Threadgill
0
Beverly Threadgill

Because he's more believable. He's so sure of himself that he'll convince the audience that he is indeed, St. Nicholas. And Miracle on 34th is my all time favorite Christmas Movie...

Reply
Annette Holloway
0
Annette Holloway

I love miracle on 34th street My favorite movie of all times

Reply
Kelly Schulz
0
Kelly Schulz

I like the older version better feels more real🎅🏼

Reply
Noreen
0
Noreen

He is the real Santa... I believe

Reply
Mattie J Bess
0
Mattie J Bess

This was the original Christmas Santa Movie that made you believe that there really was a Santa Claus. Entertaining for you and your children.

Reply

58%
It's a Wonderful Life WINNER

13

42%
Miracle on 24th Street

2

58%
It's a Wonderful Life

11 Comments
Canon Lyn
0
Canon Lyn

I mean, c'mon...there's no contest here. Angel wings, Zuzu's petals, the whole town fighting the 'system' to help him. A love story. It has it all. And Jimmy Stewart...

Reply
Angela
Angela

I love that movie so much it makes you appreciate to be alive and what you have.

Jane Schumin
0
Jane Schumin

I have watched this movie since I was a child and, now at 72, I look forward to seeing it again. The message is very powerful to me.

Reply
George Spence
0
George Spence

A great movie. Your emotions pours out!

Reply
Charlene Creer
0
Charlene Creer

All time favorite

Reply
Kathy McNulty Whitten
0
Kathy McNulty Whitten

It's the true meaning behind Christmas family not Santa

Reply
Ivy Bloom
0
Ivy Bloom

its the ultiimate christmas movie. there is no other christmas movie like its a wonderful life, far far better than miracle on 24th street

Reply
Michelle Jones
0
Michelle Jones

It's the best movie ever, no matter the season!

Reply
Janet Pacheco Cayer
0
Janet Pacheco Cayer

i love this Movie watch it every year, along with other wonderful Christmas movies

Reply
Ry88
0
Ry88

George Bailey is a real one!

Reply
Hallelujah Redeemed
Hallelujah Redeemed

Yes! Amen! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

Angela
0
Angela

I love when he comes back and sees his kids

Reply

42%
Miracle on 24th Street

2 Comments
Linda Scuzzese
0
Linda Scuzzese

MY FAVORITE CHRISTMAS MOVIE. NATALIE WOOD IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE ACTRESSES. ALL THE ACTORS IN THIS MOVIE WERE WONDERFUL.

Reply
Sophia McGrew
0
Sophia McGrew

Because it's not played constantly every day, all day. Plus I like Natalie Wood and the storyline

Reply

Always

22 Comments
Susan Mclaughlin
1
Susan Mclaughlin

I try whenever I can.

Reply
Barry Rashford
1
Barry Rashford

If we want a plastic ocean then we should continue to do what we are doing.

Reply
k san
0
k san

Because it is the right thing to do.

Reply
Larry Ewart
0
Larry Ewart

As much as possible

Reply
Sarah Croom
0
Sarah Croom

I do but I go rounds w/ my guy. Ever since China stopped taking our recycling he stopped doing it. Idk if all that is real, I have noticed that our garbage guy just loads both cans into the same dump bin & it’s not sorted. So that’s really disturbing. Every little bit helps I feel. I rec. everything

Reply
Carolyn Morris
0
Carolyn Morris

Always, I Re Use Water Bottles.

Reply
Misty Schrotberger
0
Misty Schrotberger

My mom has a cow if we don't

Reply
kaycstamper
0
kaycstamper

I do what I can but live in an area where they don't have it. Still I save bottles and cardboard to take to recycling. I cook from scratch so don't really have cans.

Reply
Michael Stafford
0
Michael Stafford

It is the least we can do to preserve our resources.

Reply
Julie Brantley
0
Julie Brantley

We pay by the pound for certain items so why not pay less and recycle - it's the right thing to do for me and the environment.

Reply
Milena Santana
0
Milena Santana

because it helps the environment

Reply
Cornelia H. Dunnings
0
Cornelia H. Dunnings

I like to help the environment. I even pick up cans & bottles near my car in parking lots.

Reply
Joyce Koch
0
Joyce Koch

I feel I'm helping out.

Reply
Linda Jeffcoat Amick
gena
gena

Although I can only hope that it's useful because there is no proof that what is supposedly sent to the recyclers they actually carry through. You always hear about it not being done.

Evey G Quines
0
Evey G Quines

It's the least I can do

Reply
Bonita Davis
0
Bonita Davis

We take our own garbage to the dump and pay by the pound. Recycling is free so the more we recycle the less we have to pay.

Reply
Jill Hoadley Chalk
0
Jill Hoadley Chalk

It's important to reuse as many things as possible.

Reply
Ann Wilbanks
0
Ann Wilbanks

Our duty to recycle. If it goes to the landfill, it piles up. Be responsible!!

Reply
Rachel Clara Smith
0
Rachel Clara Smith

Of course! Everyone should recycle!

Reply
BJ Arey
0
BJ Arey

We recycle everything possible. We also take cloth bags shopping, use insulated bag with blue ice for cold items & take reusable containers to restaurants for leftovers to take home.

Reply

Never

8 Comments
Bostino
0
Bostino

it's quite literally pointless if you do any research

Reply
Cindy Calhoun
0
Cindy Calhoun

It's not bogus I just do not have a place to drop it off in my area - if it's not close by I'm lazy and won't go out of my way (I'm a sad case).

Reply
Nancy Sam
0
Nancy Sam

I do when its readily available at airports, malls, ect. But at our home, no. I do want that to change though.

Reply
Jimmy Lancaster
0
Jimmy Lancaster

I do what I can with cardboard and such but there is no recycling program where I live

Reply
Elaine Reed
0
Elaine Reed

There is no recycling program where I live.

Reply
Nancy L Marine
0
Nancy L Marine

My local recycling company charges me to recycle, even though they're already making money on recycling that which people turn in to them.

Reply
André Luiz Macieira
0
André Luiz Macieira

becouse ay dont spique ingles vert gud

Reply
Carl Evans
0
Carl Evans

The apartment complex does not have recycle bins

Reply
Who to Follow
Jon

About Christmasmovie

Debates and polls on Christmasmovie from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT