Aldon_Smith SquareOffs

RaiderBeat Asked by RaiderBeat
1/12/2016

Can the Raiders defense overcome the loss of DE Justin Tuck?

93%
Yes. WINNER

1

7%
No.

0

93%
Yes.

This just means more playing time for the likes of Mario Edwards Jr., Denico Autry and Benson Mayowa. All of them have shown that they can be dependable, productive players. Thi... Show More
This just means more playing time for the likes of Mario Edwards Jr., Denico Autry and Benson Mayowa. All of them have shown that they can be dependable, productive players. This is when you find out what you have in other players. The defense will be fine without Tuck. Show Less
1 Comment
Kayla Lynn Hodson
Kayla Lynn Hodson

yes its possible if we can hustle this time. dont forget about the rules

Reply

7%
No.

Justin Tuck has been one of the Raiders' most consistent players, as well as an on-field leader. There's no way for them to replace what they had in Tuck, especially as a leader... Show More
Justin Tuck has been one of the Raiders' most consistent players, as well as an on-field leader. There's no way for them to replace what they had in Tuck, especially as a leader. This is a big loss. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet
RaiderBeat Asked by RaiderBeat
12/10/2015

Raiders bucked convention and signed LB Aldon Smith.

52%
That's a good thing. WINNER

0

48%
What a bad idea.

0

52%
That's a good thing.

Sometimes, you need to take risks to win in the NFL. This is a low-risk gamble, with potential huge gains. I know that Reggie McKenzie said that he wants only high-character guy... Show More
Sometimes, you need to take risks to win in the NFL. This is a low-risk gamble, with potential huge gains. I know that Reggie McKenzie said that he wants only high-character guys, but he needs to do what it takes to win more games. This is a great signing. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet

48%
What a bad idea.

This is a sign of desperation by the Raiders. They think they can succeed where the 49ers failed. How many chances did Aldon Smith get with the 49ers? He never learned. He's jus... Show More
This is a sign of desperation by the Raiders. They think they can succeed where the 49ers failed. How many chances did Aldon Smith get with the 49ers? He never learned. He's just using the Raiders to stay in shape so that he can cash in on a massive deal in free agency next season. Don't like this signing one bit. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet
RaiderBeat Asked by RaiderBeat
11/6/2015

Should the Raiders take a chance on oft-troubled LB Aldon Smith?

60%
Yes. WINNER

4

40%
No.

0

60%
Yes.

The Raiders need a proven pass rusher. If they sign Aldon Smith, they can team him with Khalil Mack and boast of one of the top rush tandems in the league.
The Raiders need a proven pass rusher. If they sign Aldon Smith, they can team him with Khalil Mack and boast of one of the top rush tandems in the league. Show Less
4 Comments
Eddie Park
Eddie Park

We have real deal ken norton jr to coach this guy up Raidernation needs this guy.

Reply
Angel Deleon
Angel Deleon

Fresh start new tea

Reply
Juan Garcia
Juan Garcia

Because someone else will . And he got mad potent

Reply
Jose Gonzalez
Jose Gonzalez

Jack nd ken Jr can check him

Reply

40%
No.

General manager Reggie McKenzie has done a nice job of bringing in high-character players. Making an exception for Aldon Smith, regardless how talented Smith is, would undermine... Show More
General manager Reggie McKenzie has done a nice job of bringing in high-character players. Making an exception for Aldon Smith, regardless how talented Smith is, would undermine McKenzie's philosophy and set a bad precedent. Show Less
0 Comment
No one has commented yet
Trending
ESports
NBA - Hot Topics 🔥
NFL 🏈
Home Run Baseball Debates ⚾️
Packers 
Who to Follow
Tucker Newkirk
Tucker Newkirk @tucker-newkirk
Jake Goalden
Jake Goalden @jake-goalden
Waira
Waira @ItsWaira

About Aldon_smith

Debates and polls on Aldon_smith from the SquareOffs community. Vote on real questions, see how the public is split, and back your side with a defense.

Become a Partner

Get SquareOffs on Your Site

📱 Download the App: iOS

Support  Publishers  About  Blog  Shop   X  Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn  YouTube  Privacy  Terms  Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information  Community Guidelines © 2026 SquareOffs Social Polling Platform

We use cookies to ensure you get the best possible experience on our website. Learn more OK, GOT IT