Which is the better episode?

It often played in a double-feature. My 5-year-old sister who had been crying because the dogs and cat in "The Incredible Journey" (the first one) were never going to get home, perked up at Sindbad. When some guy got stabbed with a sword, she said to my mom, "Now this is a good picture."

Those Russo Finnish films are among the best eps MST ever did. Ultimately I would love to see all four in this year's marathon.

All of the Hercules movies are just awful.

WHY MUST I CHOOOOOSE? They're both great, but I guess I haven't seen Sinbad as much as I've seen Hercules.

One of the first episodes I watched!

Those Russo-Finnish fantasies are some of my favorites!

We need the Bluebird of Happiness right now

The bird of happiness and the under the sea musical make that movie extremely riffable.

It's great to hear that they're BOTH winners.

It more gooder

Let me look in my dictionary... ah yes, the very definition of "so bad it's good" is "The Magic Voyage of Sinbad."

That's not Sinbad!

That beard, though.

Coin flip

Simply because more stuff happens

Our Hero is not known in other countries? Quick rename him after one of theirs for marketing! Not Sinbad, but good fun :)

On of the all-time greats. But he is NOT Sinbad.

It takes me to my happy place.