Which is your favored experiment?
MST3K Asked by MST3K
10/24/2020

Which is your favored experiment?

36%
The Rebel Set

20

64%
The Sinister Urge WINNER

32

36%
The Rebel Set

20 Comments
Mike Aronow
4
Mike Aronow

Who is Merritt Stone?!?!?

Reply
Hilary Aronow
2
Hilary Aronow

Johnny at the Fair is one of my favorite shorts with some of the most hilariously dark riffs: “Johnny feels dark hands pressing him onward. The voices in his head start to get meaner.”

Reply
Gregory Strain
2
Gregory Strain

I voted for this one for the kicks

Reply
Bill Price
0
Bill Price

This is my all time favorite episode, so I would love to see it on the marathon.

Reply
Chuck Jaeger
0
Chuck Jaeger

"A rose, by any other name, would still have thorns." "Uhh, I think you're misquoting there."

Reply
Kim VanHooser
0
Kim VanHooser

Love both of them, but just watched The Sinister Urge, which I love! Gotta think of the kicks!

Reply
Merri Hall Cross
0
Merri Hall Cross

Tough choice but I chose this for the short

Reply
Matthew Finch
0
Matthew Finch

I find myself voting more for the Joel episodes. I don't know why. But I do like the Mike ones.

Reply
Jill r
0
Jill r

This is great movie. But it also comes with one of my favorite shirts of all time, "Johnny at the fair"😆

Reply
Paul Smith
0
Paul Smith

Sinister will win, it’s Ed Wood. IMO this is the better ep. The short’s funnier, the movie’s watchable and has a plot, the riffs are on point. But hey, Ed Wood and all. I am bugged!

Reply
Duval Guerino
0
Duval Guerino

Johnny at the Fair was quite hilarious.

Reply
Brian Walch
0
Brian Walch

One time after watching this episode, I became curious enough to try looking up Merritt Stone on IMDb. I was barely able to find anything about him O_o

Reply
Kimberly Heiser
0
Kimberly Heiser

I haven’t seen either of these episodes, but of the two I would rather see Rebel Set. Sinister Urges sounds like the movie Touch of Satan ripped off and remade.

Reply
Troy Thomas
0
Troy Thomas

Both episodes are examples of the short tail wagging the movie dog, but I remember the riffing keeping up somewhat during Rebel Set as opposed to Sinister Urge.

Reply
Bruce Turbeville
0
Bruce Turbeville

Joe hits Johnny up for fifteen cents due to tax problems.

Reply
Michael Kilgore
0
Michael Kilgore

Johnny at the Fair rules!

Reply
Casey Killingsworth
0
Casey Killingsworth

I saw this the least recently.

Reply

64%
The Sinister Urge

32 Comments
Kevin Smith
3
Kevin Smith

I Brake For Ed Wood! 💙🙌

Reply
Troy LeMoine
2
Troy LeMoine

Ed Wood is Ed GOOD for riffin'!

Reply
Laura Moore
2
Laura Moore

Another Ed Wood masterpiece!

Reply
j c
0
j c

What's not to love about an Ed Wood classic?

Reply
Rita Lyons
0
Rita Lyons

For the Clean and Neat short. It is my favorite of the two shorts. I'm not really a big fan of either ot the experiments' movies. They are ok, but their shorts are better.

Reply
Jeff Oskins
0
Jeff Oskins

DON'T TOUCH THE BOOZE!!

Reply
Rick M
0
Rick M

Never seen this one but it sound pretty good.

Reply
Rebecca
0
Rebecca

Operator! Operator!

Reply
Brian Edsell
0
Brian Edsell

Have never seen but anything with Ed Wood and a killer short is a-ok with me.

Reply
Michael Schiavo
0
Michael Schiavo

One word: Ed Wood. Two words.

Reply
Kelly Luck
0
Kelly Luck

Ed Wood (what better directors woodn't)

Reply
DataAngel Nine
0
DataAngel Nine

There is no loser in this match-up. Both are amazing

Reply
Eviliz
0
Eviliz

It introduced me to the thrilling sport of long-distance cross country slip racing.

Reply
Dee Schendel
0
Dee Schendel

Ed Wood at his finest!

Reply
Todd Divel
0
Todd Divel

Are you kidding me? BOTH OF THEM PLEASE!!!!

Reply
Josh Ryals
0
Josh Ryals

Eager to see this one. Didn't know until I looked this one up that it was directed by Ed Wood. Love the Bride Of The Monster episode.

Reply
Dave Kochler
0
Dave Kochler

You can't go wrong with an Ed Wood movie

Reply
ChewsOn TinFoil
0
ChewsOn TinFoil

I just like the movie lol

Reply
Phyllis Lanza
0
Phyllis Lanza

You make it so hard! But Ed Wood trumps just about anything. Just about. Not going to tell you what trumps Ed Wood. Yet.

Reply
Harry Sherman
0
Harry Sherman

Some of Ed Wood's "best" work.

Reply
jeff lingenfelter
0
jeff lingenfelter

Toughest one yet for me, but Sinister by two nostrils.

Reply
Tim Delaney
0
Tim Delaney

The weird mob lady, mostly. But boy, both of these movies are so depressing. You feel bad for both the characters and the film workers.

Reply
Chuck Campbell
0
Chuck Campbell

This is a tough call, but I think this is the best of the Ed Wood episodes (thanks to its bizarre take on the "smut picture" racket). That being said, I think "Johnny at the Fair" a funnier short.

Reply